Subscriptions

Substack vs beehiiv

Same members, same price, two platforms. Here is what each one leaves you with.

The short answer

Neither platform wins everywhere: the result depends on how many members you have and what you charge.

At a $5 price, beehiiv (with its $49 monthly plan) starts keeping more than Substack once you pass about 92 members.

Fees checked 2026-11-03. Excludes payout fees, currency conversion and tax.

What you keep each month

Members × priceSubstackbeehiivDifferenceKeeps more
50 × $3$115$81.65$32.95Substack
50 × $5$201$179$22.25Substack
200 × $5$804$862$58beehiiv
200 × $10$1,668$1,833$165beehiiv
1000 × $5$4,020$4,506$486beehiiv
1000 × $10$8,340$9,361$1,021beehiiv

Per payment, by price

What each platform leaves from a single payment, before plan fees, payout fees and tax. The fixed processing fee weighs more at low prices.

PriceSubstack keepsFeebeehiiv keepsFeeKeeps more
$3$2.2923.6%$2.6112.9%beehiiv
$5$4.0219.6%$4.558.9%beehiiv
$10$8.3416.6%$9.415.9%beehiiv
$20$16.9815.1%$19.124.4%beehiiv

Use your own numbers

What the numbers leave out

  • Substack: Stripe is the only payment provider and may not be available in your country. Payout fees and tax are not included.
  • beehiiv: Needs a paid plan. $49 is an editable placeholder, so enter your real price.

Discovery, features, audience habits, payout methods that work in your country and tax treatment can matter more than a few percentage points. Read the fee pages before you decide: Substack fees and beehiiv paid subscription fees.

Frequently asked questions

Which keeps more of a $5 membership, Substack or beehiiv?

Substack keeps $4.02 and beehiiv keeps $4.55 per $5 payment before plan fees, payout fees and tax.

Is this a ranking of the best platform?

No. It only compares what you keep from the same members at the same price. Features, discovery and country availability matter too.

Primary references

Substack

Official + Stripe · checked 2026-11-03

Substack: 10% on paid subscriptions →
Substack: payments setup

Official · checked 2026-11-03

Substack Help: connecting Stripe →
beehiiv

Official comparison + secondary · checked 2026-11-02

beehiiv: comparison with Substack →