Substack vs beehiiv
Same members, same price, two platforms. Here is what each one leaves you with.
The short answer
Neither platform wins everywhere: the result depends on how many members you have and what you charge.
At a $5 price, beehiiv (with its $49 monthly plan) starts keeping more than Substack once you pass about 92 members.
Fees checked 2026-11-03. Excludes payout fees, currency conversion and tax.
What you keep each month
| Members × price | Substack | beehiiv | Difference | Keeps more |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 50 × $3 | $115 | $81.65 | $32.95 | Substack |
| 50 × $5 | $201 | $179 | $22.25 | Substack |
| 200 × $5 | $804 | $862 | $58 | beehiiv |
| 200 × $10 | $1,668 | $1,833 | $165 | beehiiv |
| 1000 × $5 | $4,020 | $4,506 | $486 | beehiiv |
| 1000 × $10 | $8,340 | $9,361 | $1,021 | beehiiv |
Per payment, by price
What each platform leaves from a single payment, before plan fees, payout fees and tax. The fixed processing fee weighs more at low prices.
| Price | Substack keeps | Fee | beehiiv keeps | Fee | Keeps more |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $3 | $2.29 | 23.6% | $2.61 | 12.9% | beehiiv |
| $5 | $4.02 | 19.6% | $4.55 | 8.9% | beehiiv |
| $10 | $8.34 | 16.6% | $9.41 | 5.9% | beehiiv |
| $20 | $16.98 | 15.1% | $19.12 | 4.4% | beehiiv |
What the numbers leave out
- Substack: Stripe is the only payment provider and may not be available in your country. Payout fees and tax are not included.
- beehiiv: Needs a paid plan. $49 is an editable placeholder, so enter your real price.
Discovery, features, audience habits, payout methods that work in your country and tax treatment can matter more than a few percentage points. Read the fee pages before you decide: Substack fees and beehiiv paid subscription fees.
Frequently asked questions
Which keeps more of a $5 membership, Substack or beehiiv?
Substack keeps $4.02 and beehiiv keeps $4.55 per $5 payment before plan fees, payout fees and tax.
Is this a ranking of the best platform?
No. It only compares what you keep from the same members at the same price. Features, discovery and country availability matter too.
Primary references
Official + Stripe · checked 2026-11-03
Substack: 10% on paid subscriptions →Official · checked 2026-11-03
Substack Help: connecting Stripe →Official comparison + secondary · checked 2026-11-02
beehiiv: comparison with Substack →