Blog · Subscriptions

Patreon vs Substack vs Ko-fi vs beehiiv vs YouTube Memberships: Fees Compared

Membership platforms advertise a headline fee, but what you keep is the headline fee, plus card processing, plus any plan cost. This guide puts six options side by side with the arithmetic shown, and flags what we could not verify.

Published November 13, 2026 · 16 min read · Benchmark model reviewed 3 Nov 2026

Short answer: on a $5 monthly member, our fee model has you keeping about $4.56 on Ko-fi Gold and beehiiv before their plan cost, $4.31 on Buy Me a Coffee, $4.31 on Ko-fi Free, $4.06 on Patreon, $4.02 on Substack and $3.50 on YouTube memberships. Monthly plan costs change the ranking at small member counts. Use our subscription fee calculator to test your own numbers.

Estimates, not promises. Every dollar figure on this page is a scenario computed from the Views-to-Money benchmark model (reviewed 3 Nov 2026). Real payouts depend on ads sold, audience country, content type and each platform's current rules. How we calculate →
HOW WE CALCULATE

What does "what you keep" include?

Three layers: the platform's cut, payment processing, and any monthly plan fee. For each member, our model takes the price, subtracts the platform percentage, subtracts card processing (a percentage plus a fixed fee), and then subtracts any monthly plan cost once for the whole account. Patreon also has a 2.5% currency conversion fee that we show separately. Payout fees, app-store fees and taxes are excluded, because they vary by country and method.

Our data file records the fee source for each platform and the date we last checked it (2 or 3 November 2026 for all of them). Two of the six, YouTube memberships and part of beehiiv's pricing, rest on secondary sources, and we mark them that way. If a platform changes its fees, its own help page wins.

PER MEMBER

What do you keep from one $5 member?

Between $3.50 and $4.56 before plan costs.

PlatformPer $5 member: platform cutProcessingYou keepShare kept
Patreon$0.50$0.45$4.0681.1%
Substack$0.50$0.48$4.0280.4%
Ko-fi (Free)$0.25$0.45$4.3186.1%
Ko-fi Gold$0.00$0.45$4.5691.1%
Buy Me a Coffee$0.25$0.45$4.3186.1%
beehiiv$0.00$0.45$4.5691.1%
YouTube memberships$1.50$0.00$3.5070.0%

Notice the fixed 30 cents. Where a processor charges 2.9% plus $0.30, a $5 member pays $0.445 in processing, about 8.9% of the price, and a $3 member pays $0.387, about 12.9%. Low-priced tiers lose a bigger share to fixed fees. That is why Patreon's lower-price rate and fixed fee matter at $3 or less, as our model applies a different processing rule there (5% plus $0.10, from a secondary source).

AT SCALE: $5

What does a $5 tier earn at different member counts?

This is the monthly take-home after fees and any plan cost.

Platform10 members100 members500 members1,000 members
Patreon$40.55$405.50$2,027.50$4,055.00
Substack$40.20$402.00$2,010.00$4,020.00
Ko-fi (Free)$43.05$430.50$2,152.50$4,305.00
Ko-fi Gold$33.55$443.50$2,265.50$4,543.00
Buy Me a Coffee$43.05$430.50$2,152.50$4,305.00
beehiiv−$3.45$406.50$2,228.50$4,506.00
YouTube memberships$35.00$350.00$1,750.00$3,500.00

At ten members the plan-fee platforms look poor: Ko-fi Gold costs $12 a month and beehiiv's placeholder plan is $49, both of which can exceed the whole income. By 500 members, the zero-percent platforms lead. The ranking among the percentage-fee platforms is stable: Buy Me a Coffee and Ko-fi Free keep more than Patreon and Substack, and YouTube is lower because its share is 30%.

AT SCALE: $10

What changes at $10 and at $3?

Higher prices improve your share because the fixed fee shrinks in proportion. The $10 table:

Platform10 members100 members500 members1,000 members
Patreon$84.10$841.00$4,205.00$8,410.00
Substack$83.40$834.00$4,170.00$8,340.00
Ko-fi (Free)$89.10$891.00$4,455.00$8,910.00
Ko-fi Gold$82.10$929.00$4,693.00$9,398.00
Buy Me a Coffee$89.10$891.00$4,455.00$8,910.00
beehiiv$45.10$892.00$4,656.00$9,361.00
YouTube memberships$70.00$700.00$3,500.00$7,000.00

And the $3 table, where Patreon uses its lower-price rule:

Platform10 members100 members500 members1,000 members
Patreon$24.50$245.00$1,225.00$2,450.00
Substack$22.92$229.20$1,146.00$2,292.00
Ko-fi (Free)$24.63$246.30$1,231.50$2,463.00
Ko-fi Gold$14.13$249.30$1,294.50$2,601.00
Buy Me a Coffee$24.63$246.30$1,231.50$2,463.00
beehiiv−$22.87$212.30$1,257.50$2,564.00
YouTube memberships$21.00$210.00$1,050.00$2,100.00

Compare 1,000 members at $3 and at $10 on Patreon: $2,450 and $8,410. The second is 3.4 times the first for 3.3 times the price, so a higher tier slightly improves the share you keep.

BREAK-EVEN

When does paying for a plan beat a free one?

When the extra members save you more in fees than the plan costs. The break-even is the plan cost divided by the per-member saving.

ComparisonPrice per memberMembers needed to break even
Ko-fi Gold ($12 a month) vs Ko-fi Free$548
beehiiv ($49 plan placeholder) vs Substack$592
beehiiv ($49 plan placeholder) vs Substack$1046

For Ko-fi Gold against Ko-fi Free at $5, each member saves you 5% of $5, which is $0.25, so the $12 plan pays for itself at 48 members ($48 in monthly revenue). For beehiiv against Substack at $5, each member saves $0.535, so the $49 placeholder plan needs 92 members. Because we cannot verify beehiiv's current plan price, replace $49 with your real price in the calculator before you rely on this number.

CURRENCY

What does Patreon's currency conversion fee do?

It takes another 2.5% when the patron pays in a currency other than your payout currency. For a $5 member, 2.5% is $0.125.

PlatformYou keep per $5 member, no conversionWith 2.5% conversion fee
Patreon$4.06$3.93

If many of your patrons pay in a different currency, take this into account. Our calculator has a checkbox for it. We do not model the equivalent charges for other platforms because we could not verify them. Third parties report extra international surcharges on Buy Me a Coffee, but we have not confirmed them and have not included them.

PATREON LOW PRICES

Why does the price tier matter so much on Patreon?

Because our model applies a different processing rule at $3 or less. Patreon's help centre sets processing at 2.9% plus $0.30 above $3. For $3 and under, we model 5% plus $0.10, which comes from a secondary source, so treat it as an estimate:

PricePatreon keeps from the patron (platform + processing)You keepShare kept
$3$0.55$2.4581.7%
$5$0.95$4.0681.1%
$10$1.59$8.4184.1%

The pattern holds even if the exact low-price rule changes: small tiers lose more of their value to fixed fees. If your audience is willing to pay $5 or $10, a single mid-price tier usually keeps more of the money than several $1 to $3 tiers.

NOT ONLY FEES

What else should decide the choice?

  • Where your audience is. YouTube members are already on YouTube. A newsletter reader may prefer Substack or beehiiv. A community around art may prefer Ko-fi or Patreon.
  • Ownership of the audience list. Email-first platforms give you a subscriber list you can export. Check each platform's export policy.
  • Tools. Posting, messaging, analytics, discount codes and integrations differ.
  • Payments by country. Substack uses Stripe only, which may not be available everywhere. Check payout options for your country.
  • Taxes. Platform income is taxable in most places. See our guide to tax withholding outside the US.
  • Risk. Platforms change fees. Relying on one is a business risk.
A WORKED CHOICE

Which one would suit a 300-member newsletter at $8?

Compare the monthly take-home on three candidates.

  1. Substack: price $8, platform 10% = $0.80, processing 2.9% + 0.7% = $0.288 plus $0.30, so you keep $6.612 per member. 300 members: $1,983.60.
  2. beehiiv: platform 0%, processing 2.9% = $0.232 plus $0.30, so you keep $7.468 per member. 300 members: $2,191.40 after the $49 plan placeholder.
  3. Ko-fi Gold: 0% platform, same processing: $2,228.40 after the $12 plan.

On pure fees, beehiiv and Ko-fi Gold beat Substack at this size, with beehiiv ahead of Substack by $207.80 a month. That is a few percent of revenue, so features and where your readers are may matter more than the gap.

A YEAR

What does a growing, leaking membership earn over twelve months?

A flat member count flatters every platform, so test a realistic one. Suppose you start with 200 members at $5, add 20 new ones each month and lose 5% of the base each month. The member count in month 12 is about 292. Adding up twelve months of take-home after fees and plan costs gives:

PlatformTwelve-month take-home (200 members at start, +20 a month, 5% lost a month, $5 tier)
Ko-fi Gold$13,764.09
beehiiv$13,320.09
Ko-fi (Free)$13,144.75
Buy Me a Coffee$13,144.75
Patreon$12,381.41
Substack$12,274.54
YouTube memberships$10,686.79

The leader is Ko-fi Gold at $13,764.09 for the year and the lowest is YouTube memberships at $10,686.79, a difference of $3,077.30. In this scenario the plan cost is spread across a large base, so the zero-percent platforms come out ahead. The 5% monthly loss and the 20 new members are our illustrations, not benchmarks, and we do not claim they describe any particular creator. Replace them with your own churn and growth.

PRICING

How should fees affect the tiers you offer?

Fees are a reason to simplify, not to inflate. Three practical points follow from the tables. First, a fixed charge of 30 cents hurts low tiers most, so a $2 tier keeps roughly 80% on Patreon under our low-price rule while a $10 tier keeps 84.1%. Second, annual plans, where a platform offers them, charge the fixed fee once a year instead of twelve times, which can raise your share, but we have not verified how each platform treats annual billing and have not modelled it. Third, avoid pricing around the break-even of a plan fee. If you are close to the point where a paid plan pays for itself, a small change in members can flip the result.

Think about what a member gets as well. A tier that offers something real, such as early access, a members-only post, a discount or a community space, is far easier to sell at $5 or $8 than one that offers a thank-you at $1. Fee efficiency matters only after you have members.

YOUTUBE

Where do YouTube memberships fit?

They are the simplest and, in our model, the most expensive option per member, but they live where your viewers already are. A 30% share on a $5 member leaves $3.50. A creator who sells memberships to existing viewers saves the trouble of moving people to another site, and the member count on YouTube may be higher for that reason. Secondary sources say YouTube covers card processing, but taxes and app-store fees may reduce the payout, so check YouTube Studio.

Many creators use two layers: YouTube memberships for viewers who want a quick perk, and a second platform (Patreon, Ko-fi or a newsletter) for people who want more. Our YouTube memberships fee page models the first, and the others have their own pages in the same section.

THREE QUESTIONS

What three questions settle most choices?

Ask these in order. First: where do my paying people already spend time? A membership on a platform they never visit converts badly, whatever the fee. Second: how many members do I realistically expect in six months? Below about 50 to 100 at $5, the free-plan platforms usually win because a monthly plan fee eats a big share. Third: what will I need beyond payments, such as email delivery, community tools or exports? If the answer is a lot, a platform with those tools can be worth a slightly higher fee.

Write down your answers and a six-month member estimate, then run both in the calculator. If two platforms are within a few dollars a month, pick the one your members find easiest to join, since an easy sign-up brings more members than a slightly better fee.

MISTAKES

What mistakes make fee comparisons wrong?

  • Comparing only the headline percentage and forgetting processing.
  • Ignoring the monthly plan on beehiiv and Ko-fi Gold.
  • Assuming YouTube's 30% includes or excludes taxes and app-store fees without checking Studio.
  • Using an old fee. Platforms revise fees, and new creators may be on different terms from legacy ones. Patreon, for example, applies a 10% fee to pages published after 4 August 2025, and legacy plans keep their old pricing.
  • Forgetting that members cancel. Model a drop of some members each month.
  • Leaving out your own tax.
TROUBLESHOOTING

My real payout is lower than the calculator. Why?

Look at what the model leaves out. Payout fees (for example PayPal or bank transfer costs), failed payments, refunds, chargebacks, app-store fees if members subscribed through an app, currency conversion on your side, and tax withholding all reduce what reaches your account. Add them one at a time against a real statement. If the difference is more than a few percent after you have included these, one of the fee assumptions on our page may be out of date. Tell us through the contact page and include the platform, the price and your statement lines.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Which membership platform keeps the most for creators?

On a $5 member in our model, the zero-percent platforms (Ko-fi Gold and beehiiv) keep the most per member, but they charge a monthly plan, so they win only once you have enough members.

What is the YouTube memberships share?

Secondary sources consistently report that YouTube keeps 30% and creators receive 70%. Confirm in YouTube Studio, because taxes and app-store fees can change the payout.

Does Patreon charge a conversion fee?

Our data records a 2.5% currency conversion fee when the patron pays in a different currency from your payout currency.

Are payout fees included?

No. Payout fees, app-store fees and taxes on fees are excluded.

Is the beehiiv plan price correct?

The $49 figure is a placeholder based on secondary sources that quote roughly $43 to $49 a month for the plan that includes paid subscriptions. Edit it to your real price.

How often do you update this?

Fee data was last checked on 2 to 3 November 2026. Fees change, so check each platform's help page.

Sources

Sources and how we treated them

Fee pages are the official help pages where available. YouTube memberships and beehiiv's plan price rest on secondary sources and are labelled in our data. Fees change, so open the linked page before you decide.

Patreon Help Center: creator fees

Fee model and the 2.5% conversion fee.

Open source →
Substack: 10% on paid subscriptions

10% of paid subscriptions plus Stripe.

Open source →
Ko-fi Help: does Ko-fi take a fee?

5% on memberships on the free plan.

Open source →
Ko-fi Help: what is Ko-fi Gold?

0% service fee for $12 a month.

Open source →
Buy Me a Coffee Help: charges on your payment

5% platform fee.

Open source →
beehiiv: comparison with Substack

0% take on paid subscriptions; plan price from secondary sources.

Open source →
Creator Essentials: channel memberships

Secondary source for YouTube's 30/70 split.

Open source →
Views-to-Money subscription fee data

Fee data and last-checked dates.

Open source →